Judgment, Decree & Order

In the context of Civil Procedure Code (CPC), Judgment, Decree, and Order are important terms that define the various types of decisions made by a court. Each of these terms plays a distinct role in the judicial process, and understanding their differences is vital for understanding how legal matters are concluded.

---

Judgment

Definition

A judgment is the final decision made by a court after hearing a case. It contains the reasoning behind the court’s decision on the issues raised by the parties in the suit.

Under Section 2(9) of the CPC, the term judgment is defined as:

• Judgment means the statement given by the judge on the grounds of a decree or order. It contains the court’s reasoning and conclusions.

Characteristics of a Judgment

1. Final Decision: A judgment concludes the rights of the parties in the dispute and may either dismiss or uphold the claims made.
2. Reasoned Opinion: It includes the reasoning for the court’s decision, addressing each issue raised in the case.
3. Basis for Appeal: The judgment forms the basis for an appeal in case one of the parties is aggrieved by the decision.
4. Must be Pronounced in Open Court: A judgment must be delivered in open court, and it must be recorded.

Types of Judgment

1. Interlocutory Judgment: A judgment given during the proceedings but not concluding the entire matter. It usually relates to specific interim orders, like an injunction or stay.
2. Final Judgment: A decision that ends the case, resolving the matter on its merits.

Example

• In a case involving a dispute over land ownership, the court will issue a judgment stating which party is the rightful owner based on the evidence presented.

---

Decree

Definition

A decree is the formal expression of an adjudication by a court, which conclusively determines the rights of the parties in respect to all or any of the matters in the suit.

Section 2(2) of the CPC defines Decree as:

• Decree means the formal expression of an adjudication, which definitively determines the rights of the parties with respect to all or any of the matters in controversy in the suit.

Types of Decrees

1. Preliminary Decree: A decree that does not finally dispose of the suit but leaves some matters for further determination (e.g., a decree for partition that leaves the actual division of property to be decided later).
2. Final Decree: A decree that finally disposes of the suit, giving a definite decision on all issues.
3. Conditional Decree: A decree that requires the fulfillment of certain conditions before it becomes effective.
4. Consent Decree: A decree passed with the consent of both parties, usually when they have settled their disputes outside the court.
5. Ex Parte Decree: A decree passed in favor of the plaintiff when the defendant is not present in court, i.e., when the defendant is absent from the proceedings.

Characteristics of a Decree

1. Definitive: It definitively decides the rights of the parties regarding the subject matter of the suit.
2. Formal Expression: A decree is a formal document that marks the end of litigation.
3. Appealable: A decree can be appealed if one of the parties is dissatisfied with the decision.

Example

• In a suit for divorce, the decree will legally end the marriage between the parties.

---

Order

Definition

An order refers to any decision passed by a court, except a judgment or a decree. Orders are made in the course of proceedings and may not necessarily determine the final rights of the parties.

Section 2(14) of the CPC defines Order as:

• Order means the formal expression of any decision of a civil court which is not a decree.

Types of Orders

1. Interlocutory Order: An order passed during the pendency of a case, typically dealing with procedural matters like interim injunctions, stay orders, etc.
2. Final Order: An order that concludes the proceedings in a particular issue but does not end the entire case.
3. Conditional Order: An order that imposes conditions on a party, for example, an order to pay a sum of money for a stay.
4. Interim Order: Temporary orders passed before the final judgment or decree, for example, temporary reliefs like stay or injunctions.
5. Execution Order: An order issued to enforce a decree.

Characteristics of an Order

1. Procedural: Orders typically concern procedural matters and may not be based on the final adjudication of the dispute.
2. Appealable or Not: Not all orders are appealable. Only orders specified in the CPC or those that affect the rights of parties can be appealed.
3. Can Be Interim or Final: Orders can be interim (temporary) or final, depending on the stage of the proceedings.

Example

• An order passed by the court granting a temporary injunction to prevent a party from selling property during the pendency of a suit.

---

Differences Between Judgment, Decree, and Order

Criteria	Judgment	Decree	Order
Definition	A statement of the court’s decision and reasons for it.	Formal expression of an adjudication determining the rights of parties.	Formal expression of a decision that is not a decree or judgment.
Purpose	To give reasons for the court’s decision.	To conclusively determine the rights of the parties in respect to the matter in controversy.	To deal with procedural matters and interim directions.
Effect	Does not resolve the entire dispute but clarifies the legal standing of the case.	Resolves the entire dispute or a part of it in a final manner.	Can be procedural, not always final in nature.
Appealability	Can be appealed if it affects the final decision.	Can be appealed, depending on the nature (preliminary or final).	Some orders can be appealed, others cannot (e.g., interim orders).
Stage	Typically pronounced after full trial or hearing.	After the case is decided, either partially or fully.	Can occur at any stage of the proceedings, including during interim stages.
Example	A court ruling on the merits of a case, like a divorce.	A decree declaring the dissolution of marriage.	A court order granting a temporary injunction or stay.

---

Case Laws Related to Judgment, Decree & Order

1. Nathulal v. State of Madhya Pradesh (1966): The Supreme Court observed that a judgment is a final decision that explains the reasoning behind the court’s verdict, whereas a decree expresses the court’s decision in a formal and legally enforceable form.
2. K.K. Verma v. Union of India (1954): In this case, the court ruled that an order cannot be confused with a judgment or decree, as orders generally address procedural matters and are typically non-final decisions.

---

Conclusion

• Judgment, Decree, and Order are fundamental concepts in the Indian legal system. Understanding these distinctions helps in determining the finality, appealability, and purpose of the decisions made by the courts.
• Judgments are the reasoned conclusions of a case, decrees formalize the court’s decision, and orders deal with procedural issues.
• These terms reflect the structure and flow of civil litigation and ensure that the judicial process runs in an orderly and efficient manner.